Digital age ‘desperately’ needs ethical and legal guidelines



This post Digital age ‘desperately’ needs ethical and legal guidelines was originally published on Horizon: the EU Research & Innovation magazine | European Commission.

Image credit – ITU Pictures, licensed under CC BY 2.0.

Jeroen van den Hoven, professor of ethics and technology at Delft University of Technology in the Netherlands, was speaking at a session on ethics in science and technology at the EuroScience Open Forum (ESOF) 2018, which is being held in Toulouse, France, from 9-14 July.

‘People are becoming aware that this digital age is not neutral…, it is presented to us mainly by big corporations who want to make some profit,’ he said.

He called for a Europe-wide network of institutions that can provide a set of values, based on the EU’s Charter of Fundamental Rights, which the technology industry could operate within.

‘We have to set up, as we’ve done for food, for aviation and for traffic, … an elaborate system of institutions that will look (at) this field of artificial intelligence.

‘We need to think about governance, inspection, monitoring, testing, certification, classification, standardisation, education, all of these things. They are not there.  We need to desperately, and very quickly, help ourselves to it.’

Prof. van den Hoven is a member of the European Group on Ethics in Science and New Technologies (EGE), an independent advisory body for the European Commission, which organised the session he was speaking at.

In March, the EGE published a statement on artificial intelligence (AI), robotics and autonomous systems, which criticised the current ‘patchwork of disparate initiatives’ in Europe that try to tackle the social, legal and ethical questions that AI has generated. In the statement, the EGE called for the establishment of a structured framework.

The European Commission announced on 14 June that they have tasked a high-level group of 52 people from academia, society and industry with the job of developing guidelines on the EU’s AI-related policy, including ethical issues such as fairness, safety, transparency and the upholding of fundamental rights.

The expert group, which includes representatives from industry leaders in AI such as Google, BMW and Santander, are due to present their guidelines to the European Commission at the beginning of 2019.

‘People are becoming aware that this digital age is not neutral…, it is presented to us mainly by big corporations who want to make some profit.’

Professor Jeroen van den Hoven, Delft University of Technology, Netherlands


Ethical issues surrounding AI ­– such as bias in machine learning algorithms and how to oversee the decision-making of autonomous machines – also attracted widespread discussion at the ESOF 2018 conference.

One major concern emerging with the fast-paced development of machine learning, is the question of how to account for the actions of a machine. This is a particular issue when using AI based on neural networks, a complex system set up to mimic the human brain that enables it to learn from large sets of data. This often results in algorithm becoming what is known as a ‘black box’, where it’s possible to see what goes in and what comes out, but not how the outcome was arrived at.

Maaike Harbers, a research professor at the Rotterdam University of Applied Sciences in the Netherlands, said that this was an important issue in the military, where weaponised drones are used to carry out actions.

‘In the military domain, a very important concept is meaningful human control,’ she said. ‘We can only control or direct autonomous machines if we understand what is going on.’

Prof. Harbers added that good design of the interface between humans and machines can help ensure humans exercise control at three important stages – data input, processing and reasoning, and the output or action.

Even in technologies that use AI for purposes that seem to be overwhelmingly positive, such as companion social robots for children, raise some tricky ethical issues. The conference audience heard that researchers working in this area are grappling with the effect these technologies can have on family relationships, for example, or whether they could create inequalities in society, or if they might create social isolation.

In the field of automated transport, researchers are also looking at the impact self-driving cars might have on wider issues such as justice and equality. They are investigating questions ranging from how to ensure equal access to new forms of transport to who should benefit from any cost-savings associated with automated transport.

However, the values we instil in AI may be a key factor in public acceptance of new technologies.

One of the most well-known moral dilemmas involving self-driving cars, for example, is the so-called trolley problem. This poses the question of whether an autonomous vehicle heading towards an accident involving a group people should avoid it by swerving onto a path that would hit just one person.

Dr Ebru Burcu Dogan from the Vedecom Institute in France, said research shows that while people were in favour of a utilitarian solution to the dilemma – for example, killing the driver rather than five pedestrians – they personally wouldn’t want to buy or ride in a vehicle that was programmed in such a way.

‘We all want to benefit from the implementation of a technology, but we don’t necessarily want to change our behaviour, or adopt a necessary behaviour to get there.’

If you liked this article, please share it.

This post Digital age ‘desperately’ needs ethical and legal guidelines was originally published on Horizon: the EU Research & Innovation magazine | European Commission.


Leave a Reply

Related Articles

Webinar: Dreaming of AI: Perspectives on AI Use in Cultural Heritage
BPOC - BALBOA PARK ONLINE COLLABORATIVE is facilitating another open discussion on the use of AI in cultural heritage. In this session, we have invited Kerry Kennedy, Public Art Coordinator with the DC Commission on the Arts and Humanities, and Dr. Eve Zucker, Sociocultural Anthropologist, to open up our conversation. Kerry and Eve will talk about their work, AI's role and impact, and ethical considerations in the first part of the webinar. In the second part, audience members will be invited...
EAI ArtsIT 2021 - 10th EAI International Conference: ArtsIT, Interactivity & Game Creation
ArtsIT takes place from December 2nd to 4th as a hybrid event at the UNESCO Creative City of Media Arts Karlsruhe, Germany, and in Cyberspace. The conference brings together researchers, practitioners, artists, and academia to present and discuss the symbiosis between art and information technology. Since 2009 ArtsIT has become a leading scientific forum for the dissemination of cutting-edge research results in the intersection between art, science, culture, performing arts, media, and te...
CENTAUR, one more premiere for ADAF ONLINE
The 16th international festival for digital arts of Greece, Athens Digital Arts Festival (ADAF), the pioneer longest living institution dedicated to digital culture in the country (est.2005), is launching the Online era and continues its daily activities presenting even more world premieres at ADAF ONLINE. It is the first Digital Art Online Streaming Festival held in Greece, and is announcing another premiere. On September 4 and 10, 2020, ADAF ONLINE will present for the first time in Greece ...
Call for Papers: ​BOBCATSSS 2025
  The BOBCATSSS conference is an international annual academic event focusing on library and information science. It is primarily organized by and from students from various universities across Europe. BOBCATSSS 2025 will take place on 21-23 January 2025, in Istanbul, under the  theme "Artificial Intelligence in Library and Information Science: Exploring the Intersection." The rapid advancements in Artificial Intelligence are reshaping the landscape of Library and...